Like this Batman / Hulk cross over from 1981
In that cross over Batman defeated Marvel's mightiest hero. How? Because he is the god damned Batman that's how
Cross over in regard to training means training in one discipline that crosses over and improves skills in another.
This blog entry will address both.
I'm sure you have heard the phrase - Haters gonna hate.
I’ve been “hated” on, and even though it bothers me to admit
it publicly I have “hated” on others.
Begs the question:
Have you ever “hated” on someone you are doing better than?
There are guys in the fields of close quarter combatives for
professionals (military / law enforcement) and private personal protection that
couldn’t carry my jock.
But they don’t really care because they are too busy
counting all the money they are making.
I will no longer waste time saying anything negative about
these people because no, you don’t hate on someone you are doing better than.
I’ve decided to take that energy and spend it on doing
better than them.
Easier said than done.
If it was easy I’d already be doing it.
Remember what I just wrote about saying negative things? So without wasting energy being negative let
me just say, there are practices I’ve seen that are financially viable, but I
am not willing to follow those practices.
Advertising and marketing are skill sets I do not possess
(yet..)
However, when the student is ready the teacher will appear.
Enter obligatory pop culture reference here:
Luckily for me I have found that rare flower of someone that
runs a commercially successful martial arts school and isn’t a sell out or a
douche bag.
He doesn't water down his stuff, doesn't teach children, and
he teaches martial arts and personal protection as separate things.
That brings us to the topics of this blog post
Martial Art vs. Personal Protection
And what are viable successful marketing strategies for
personal protection
Martial art vs. Self Protection
Let me start by saying I love martial arts (duh right).
I’d even go so far as to say there are no “bad” martial
arts.
Hell, I’ll even go a step further and say there is one art
that is superior to all others.
OOOooooo controversial!
Calm down, that one superior art is different for
everyone. It is the art you enjoy doing,
that becomes a part of your lifestyle, and is something you will do the rest of
your life.
As much as you love whatever that art is, no matter how bad
ass it is, you must understand that martial art is not personal protection.
If you are studying a martial art for self defense buyer beware.
No martial art is complete for personal protection in the 21st
century.
The old schools ones were used before there were laws.
The newer ones were never intended for that purpose.
However, any art can be adapted for personal protection.
To do so you will need a full range of physical skills, and
more importantly specific information your Sensei or Sifu never taught you
Physical Skills
To make my point let’s take look at a use of force
continuum.
A use of force continuum is an example of rules of
engagement found in most Law Enforcement agencies’ use of force policies.
1. Presence
Appearance
Physical Fitness
Awareness
2. Verbal
commands
De-escalation
Communication Skills
3. Contact
Controls
Touching or Seizing the offender
Escort Compliance
Standing Controls
Pain Compliance
Joint Locks
4. Compliance
Techniques
“Soft Hands”
Take Downs
Throws
Pins
5. Disabling
Techniques
“Hard Hands”
Impact Techniques
Striking / Kicking
Impact Weapons
6. Potentially
Lethal Force
Strangles
7. Lethal
Force
If you are going to employ your martial arts skills for
personal protection you must assure that your own personal style covers all
these aspects.
You will have to have skill sets at all levels of
force. I like to use this model as a
frame work for people to take the foundation of their martial arts training and
develop their own operational style.
For example:
If you have been training in Karate you should be well
versed in Disabling Techniques / “Hard Hands”.
If you want to use Karate as a foundation for personal protection or
professional use of force you will need to round out your own personal style
with skills in
- · Contact Controls
- · Compliance Techniques
- · Potentially Lethal Force
- · Lethal Force
There are fantastic throws, sweeps and take downs in Karate,
but how many Karate Instructors teach those aspects anymore? So this hypothetical person needs to find
those lost / under taught elements in his own art or seek out supplemental
training to develop those assets.
Just as I learned that Karate, Aikido, and Judo all work
together because they all evolved from the core art of JuJutsu. Anyone interested in rounding out their skill
for personal protection should look for ways that complement each other.
If you train in one system that preaches always stay on your
feet and another that suggests you pull an attacker to the ground on top of
you, how are you going to make those skill sets work together under pressure against
a violent attacker?
Your training must fit your rules of engagement, your
personal ethical codes and work in the environment you are likely to find yourself in.
So, before you seek out additional training
have an operational philosophy in mind to use as your foundation.
*If you are a professional (paid to protect others) or plan to incorporate fire arms
skills into your personal protection method, I suggest starting with fire arms skills and building around that
foundation.
For more information on that and to cover training in one discipline that crosses over and improves skills in another, please check out:
http://practicalbudo.blogspot.com/2012/08/cross-over-effect.html
Filling in the holes (don’t get cute with that)
Just as our hypothetical Karateka needed to seek out additional training. You are going to have to assess your skill sets and find ways to cover missing information. No matter what your martial arts foundation / background is,
in order to use it for personal protection you will need to know:
- How to hit hard
- Not how to earn points in competition. How to generate power and deliver force into an enemy in order to disable an attacker.
- How Joints lock / break
- How to control someone using lower levels of force, and how to break someone when higher levels of force are justified
- How to overcome an ambush attack
- Not blocking, not evading, but turning the tide. The Japanese sometimes call this Sen No Sen or attacking the attack.
You are not defending but actively counter attacking. Something that protects you and allows you to deliver force (damage) into the attacker at the same time. All while improving your position so the attacker can no longer damage you. - How throws work
- It is unlikely you will ever need to use personal protection skills against someone your own size or smaller. You need to be able to move a larger aggressive enemy. You need to be able to direct that enemy into the environment (walls, tables, the floor, down a flight of stairs)
- How to move someone on the ground
- You don't need to be a red belt in BJJ but you should be able to prevent your self from being taken to the ground, and if you end up there you have to be able to move a larger aggressive enemy.
- How strangles work - Wreck a neck
- You will need the ability to use potentially lethal force
- *Edged weapons
- *Fire arms
If you are very fortunate you may train in a system that covers most if not all of those physical skills. As complete as any system that could possibly cover all of that is, still more is needed to make those skills viable for personal protection.
More importantly than any physical skills you will need to know a block of information I like to call – things your Sensei never taught you
Understanding use of force law
Force Articulation
Force Articulation
How your brain works – this is your brain
How your brain reacts to stress caused by conflict – this is
your brain on violence
Social Violence
Asocial Violence
Conflict Strategy – Avoidance
Conflict Strategy – Escape and evade
Verbal Skills - Deescalating social violence
Verbal Skills - Deterring asocial violence
Logic of violence - Understanding criminal behavior
Threat assessment
Reading terrain
After
- · Self care
- · Talking to the police
- · Psychology of survival
No matter how good your martial arts training is, if it does
not cover all of the above topics in depth, it is incomplete for personal
protection.
How can one learn the things your Sensei never taught you?
How can one learn the things your Sensei never taught you?
Shameless self plug 1
Every fall I host the Violence Dynamics Seminar in Minnesota
featuring Rory Miller and Marc MacYoung.
Over the course of the seminar all of the above mentioned necessary
skills / knowledge is covered.
However, as you can imagine, that is a lot of stuff to cover
so the seminar usually runs 7 to 10 days.
I got to thinking, I always performed better on tests that I
prepared for in manageable study sessions over time.
As opposed to cramming for 8 hours the night before a test.
The Violence Dynamics seminar is fantastic for all, but
especially martial artists looking to fill in the holes so that their martial
arts training can be viable for personal protection. However, as good as it is 80 hours of
training over 10 days once a year is a crash course.
How could I present the information from the Violence
Dynamics Seminar in manageable portions over time?
I developed the Violence Dynamics Semester course. The semester course is 10 weeks long. Two hours every Tuesday night. Generally one hour of academic training and
one hour of physical skills.
Some weeks are entirely academic because the topic takes
more time to cover*
Academic Topics Physical
Skills
Understanding use of force How
to hit hard
This is your Brain*
This is your brain on violence*
Social Violence Joint
Locks / Breaks
Asocial Violence Counter
Ambush
Conflict Strategy – Avoidance Throwing
Mechanics
Conflict Strategy – Escape evade Ground Movement
Verbal Skills Deescalating social violence High end use of
force - Wreck a neck
Verbal Skills deterring asocial violence Physical
skills review - Drills
Logic of violence*
Threat assessment*
Reading terrain*
Fire Arms
Training
Scenarios
I found a way to cover the essential skill sets necessary
for anyone to use force (violence) legitimately for personal protection.
I even paired the Tuesday physical topics with Saturday
Seminars so people seeking additional training can benefit from taking the
fundamentals they learned on Tuesday and applying them to the same topic for
three hours the following Saturday.
This has become the favorite class I teach and although I
always look forward to teaching, I get more excited about this class than the
others.
Why? For one reason,
where I am at with my own progress and personal training this is exactly the type
of training I need. I am at a place where
I really could care less about individual arts, ranks, or organizations. I want to be the best there is at what I
do. The best I can be. This type of training is ideal for taking someone
from zero skill and getting them to proficiency as fast as possible. Focusing on training the individual, not
passing on a tradition. Which also means
it is very good for rounding out skill sets that may be lacking from any one
art.
Another reason I have found is that professional users of
force, Operators (Cops / Military) need training in personal protection.
What do I mean by this?
Just because you are skilled at using violence in one
context does not mean that those skills cross over to other aspects and rules
of engagement. No matter how bad ass you
are, at the end of the day, at the end of your tour, you will find yourself off
duty in the capacity of a civilian.
Surrounded by other civilians. If
you don’t know / have never been trained how to operate in that environment
using your bad ass skills is going to get you into a world of hurt.
Lastly, the reason I get a little more excited about this
class is it has become kind of a spy / commando class.
How to become Bourne, Bond, Bauer (or Batman)
if you will.
I would never advertise the
class as that. That was never my
intention. However, because of my
personality, and because I’m a pop culture nerd it has kind of morphed into
that.
Maybe give it a cool covert operations group acronym like
ODIN
Operational
Disciplines
Instructional
Network
Can you blame me? The
class is held in a semi secret, semi hidden subterranean training facility.
Also people learn better and quicker by playing. Playing also wires the information to the
part of the brain that will be active during conflict. So, many of the games I use or have developed
myself involve playing the role of a highly trained operative
The problem I am having is, although this is my favorite
class, I only have 3-4 students in the class.
Most of who have had this material several times before.
Remember as I stated marketing and advertising are skill sets I still need to master.
A possible solution I have come up with is turning this
class into a permit to carry class.
With all of the emphasis I put on understanding force laws there is a lot of cross over any way.
With all of the emphasis I put on understanding force laws there is a lot of cross over any way.
The pros:
Many people have asked me to do a permit to carry class
(potential clients)
Permit to carry classes fill up all the time
If people that want permit to carry class get a taste of the other things the class offer they may become regular students. Or at least continue taking this class
There are plenty of skilled martial artists around. Part of them knows they need some sort of additional training to make their skills viable for personal protection. Many do not seek out this additional training because they have a deep investment in their previous training. And even as easy going and style neutral as I am, I feel many that would benefit from training with me do not because there may be a loss of face. “I’ve spent all this time doing (insert name here) and he is saying it won’t work for personal protection”. That is not true I never say that (re-read the beginning of this blog) but sadly that may be the perception, until I can actually get them on the mat and play with them
How is that a pro? I think fire arms are so far out of normal martial art skills that it circumvents that possible perceived loss of face. Get them in the door with fire arms, don’t let them leave until they can make their existing skills viable for personal protection.
The cons:
An average permit to carry class is 6 – 10 hours
My class is at least 20 hours.
So why would anyone spend 20 hours training with me to get
the same permit to carry they could get with 6 hours of training anywhere else?
Anyone who has gone to an NRA instructor school and meets
the minimum qualifications can teach a permit to carry class.
I far exceed those qualifications (please forgive the following shameless self-plug 2)
I am an Operator on multiple different tactical teams (well two, but that sounds sexy as hell right?)
I am a sniper
I am a SWAT team leader
I am a SWAT team training coordinator (which means I teach operational skills to tactical teams)
I am a SWAT team training coordinator (which means I teach operational skills to tactical teams)
I have been hired by several tactical teams to train their personnel
I have taught at the SOTA Midwest regional SWAT conference
multiple time (well twice, but I am rolling
here)
I use what I teach professionally on a regular basis (It's not a hobby it is my profession)
Bottom line any one can teach a permit to carry class. I can teach you how to fight with a gun
(America’s martial art).
Why the distinction, why do I think the extra 14 hours is necessary?
Let’s take a look at the Martin / Zimmerman shooting. Take away any possible political leanings. Take away any possible race implications. Take away any blame. Bottom line there was a conflict between the two. The conflict became physical. Any time conflict goes physical it has the potential to become lethal. Zimmerman was losing so he used his fire arm.
My hope is in the extra 14 hours I provide, the students will
develop their own personal protection method that integrates fire arms with
other necessary physical defense skills.
So that situations like Martin / Zimmerman might not escalate to lethal
force. And if God forbid it ever did the the academic skill sets would enable students to know when lethal force is justified and be able to articulate their
actions.
Sounds like an awesome class right? You can see why I am so excited about
it. Not only is it necessary, but it is
fun and you can get your permit to carry after completion.
So how can I fill my classes?
Man needs to know his limitations. I need
help. I am not worried about losing
face, I want to develop the skills I need to fill that class.
1 I would like to make some money. I have become cool with that. Batman has money.
2 The information is no good if I can’t get the information out to the people that need it and will use it.
1 I would like to make some money. I have become cool with that. Batman has money.
2 The information is no good if I can’t get the information out to the people that need it and will use it.
Which brings us back to the beginning of this blog. The cross over, just like in the comics. That
rare flower (I'm sure he loves me calling him that) is Randy King of KPC. I met
Randy at the Violence Dynamics seminar (which he regularly attends). He also produces a video blog Randy
Rants.
Recently, we were discussing the problem I am having, and Randy’s last rant. The rant was against fear based marketing. One of those practices I will not follow that I mentioned earlier. The rant generated a lot of response. However, one internet troll wrote pages and pages on how he was wrong and basically called Randy out asking how you advertise a personal protection service if you are not going to exploit fear.
Recently, we were discussing the problem I am having, and Randy’s last rant. The rant was against fear based marketing. One of those practices I will not follow that I mentioned earlier. The rant generated a lot of response. However, one internet troll wrote pages and pages on how he was wrong and basically called Randy out asking how you advertise a personal protection service if you are not going to exploit fear.
So here is the cross over. We decided to kill several birds with one stone. I will write a blog (the one you are currently reading) on the necessity of
personal protection training different than adding the words “for self defense” to the end of any martial art you may be teaching. Kendo for self defense for example. I will also provide an example of what is required for personal
protection. Randy will help me fill the
class by showing me and the internet troll (p.s. fuck that guy) how to
successfully market that class without resorting to practices I find distasteful.
Train hard, Train Smart, Stay safe...and Stay tuned for Randy's response